Would PLoP support VHD-files?

[Bobby_ii]

have VHD-files its own boot-sector? It seem's that yes.
Now we may to boot from VHD only on kernel-level (2 ways).
2 boot from VHD now we need to boot "bootmgr" that load only {VHD_file}\Windows\system32\winload.exe or modified linux kernel from vmlite. But VHD-drive (file) should have its own boot-sector (that is used when booting under virtual machine). Is the way to boot from the boot-sector inside VHD-container?

[Elmar]

i don't understand how vhd should be supported?

[Bobby_ii]

I think, like USB - thru the driver :-) (sorry i'm 0 in programming)
.vhd - virtual drive format, have the same logical structure as physical drives.
   Win7 & Ubuntu may load from .vhd drives in physical environment (don't using virtual machines), but they use boot loader from physical drive & load from .vhd thru kernel, i need to load the boot manager from .vhd (for example, truecrypt boot manager installed in bootrecord of .vhd) and load system installed on .vhd.
I think, there is no big difference between attaching usb-drive & .vhd-container (exept the path to this .vhd container that shoud be given explicitly (sorry for broken english)).

... sorry for my appinion ....
now (i think) structure is: PLOP_boot_loader->USB_CD_drivers->boot_loader_on_selected_drive
structure for support VHD (or others aka wubi) containers should be next:
PLOP_boot_loader->fat_support(extfs2-4,fat**,ntfs :-))->container_structure_support(aka driver)->boot_loader_on_selected_container
so there is 1 important and no_easy_2_relise think - fat support :-(.

[Elmar]

ok i understand, but the next problem is to get the vhd file structure to be able to convert the virtual (and i am sure compressed) sectors back to "real" sectors. do you have docs?

[Bobby_ii]

"This specification is provided under the Microsoft Open Specification Promise."
VHD - available under free license for developers and users (tr. from russian :-)).
http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/virtualserver/bb676673.aspx  (in general)
http://download.microsoft.com/download/f/f/e/ffef50a5-07dd-4cf8-aaa3-442c0673a029/Virtual%20Hard%20Disk%20Format%20Spec_10_18_06.doc   (concrete, doc format)

VHD hardly to be compressed - it is the emulation of physical drive, i.e. empty space in begining. It may use file system compression, for example, ntfs-compression when partitioning/formatting, but it is not .vhd feature.

[Elmar]

i did a quick view over the doc and it looks good. it should be easy to write a small program to provide access to the virtual sectors and run a bootloader/boot manager from the vhd file. when i write the program, then it will be a single program and not part of the plop boot manager (maybe they merge later). the first version will work only with vhd files on fat16/32 partitions. its easier to implement fat than ntfs. currently i am busy, so it will need some time until its written.

regards
elmar

[Bobby_ii]

I think that it would be easy to implement .vhd support to GRUB then to PLOP, but thank you.

[Elmar]

I think that it would be easy to implement .vhd support to GRUB then to PLOP, but thank you.

what has it to do with grub?

[Bobby_ii]

This task is particaly solved by vmlite - they create vhd.mod and modified grub2.
I think, vmlite add .vhd support like .iso or wubi .disk support to grub 2.
But they doesn't clearly solved my problem. And they does't gave sources now - only promised to gave after all jobs complete :-). Also they promised to realise XP booting from vhd, but I don't know how it would be done.
Now vboot only doubles results of booting W7 from .vhd using bootmgr and booting Ubuntu from Wubi .disk using grub. So no generaly new result. Exept booting ubuntu from .vhd .
There's no clear way to boot internal .vhd bootmanager .

In addition - I prefer grub legacy :-) - it's lazy 2 learn grub 2 :-)

[Bobby_ii]

Ups... sorry GRUB4DOS could access .vhd drives (but nobody know it :-) including Gooooooogle!!!) but do it correctly with internal FAT and not correct with NTFS (errors with numbers of sectors occured). ext*fs hav't tested. But DOS@FAT i've loaded :-). W7@ntfs successfully loaded from bootmgr gaves bluescreen being loaded from GRUB.

[Elmar]

Ups... sorry GRUB4DOS could access .vhd drives (but nobody know it :-) including Gooooooogle!!!) but do it correctly with internal FAT and not correct with NTFS (errors with numbers of sectors occured). ext*fs hav't tested. But DOS@FAT i've loaded :-). W7@ntfs successfully loaded from bootmgr gaves bluescreen being loaded from GRUB.

i dont understand what you are telling me (except that you mean grub4dos)

yesterday evening i started with the loader
currently i wrote a small program from scratch to navigate through the fat32 file system. i know, you wish a config file, but for testing its easier to navigate through the file system and select the vhd file.

now i start with the vhd stuff.

[Elmar]

virtual sector reading works fine, now i have to write the interrupt handler 

[Elmar]

today, i spent a few hours to finish the interrupt 13. for testing, i booted a dos from a dynamic vhd file. it worked fine without any problem

-> turn on pc
-> booting fat formatted floppy with my vhd handler (can be installed to a hard disk too)
-> selected vhd file from a fat32 partition
-> booting the vhd file
-> dos is up and running from the vhd file

so, a linux that supports to run from vhd files without virtual machine should work without any problems

is there somebody still interested in that? Bobby_ii was never online again here.


regards
elmar

[Elmar]

download is available on the vhd page http://www.plop.at/en/vhdloader.html

feel free to use it

[Bazong]

Hi,

what a great tool, i canīt believe it as i read that on the homepage !

thx for that 

regards

[Icecube]

@ Elmar
Will it work with a dynamic VHD when DOS want to write to the filesystem inside the VHD?

[Elmar]

@ Elmar
Will it work with a dynamic VHD when DOS want to write to the filesystem inside the VHD?

currently, there is no write access implemented. it should be no big problem to add this. i did not spent too much time for the program, because i don't know if many people want to use it. for me, it was a chance to free the mind, because another project drives me crazy. however, its the first test release with much potential to extend and improve. personally i don't use the program, so i need input from others what features are useful.

regards
elmar

[fady_saber]

Dear Elmar:
Good news to here about PLOP VHD Loader   
I would like to know if later will be also a loader for VMDK, VDI, and Raw ??

Also Did you hear about VBoot from (  http://www.vmlite.com/index.php/products/vboot  )
it also works for booting the VHD's

Thanks
Fady

[Elmar]

I would like to know if later will be also a loader for VMDK, VDI, and Raw ??

raw is already supported, because the fixed vhd files are raw files, but the loader is listing only .vhd files.

VDMK: i don't know, currently i downloaded the specs.
VDI: i don't know, i didn't find the specs.

does people really want to boot without virtual machine from such images?

Also Did you hear about VBoot from (  http://www.vmlite.com/index.php/products/vboot  )

the topic starter said something about vmlite, but i haven't tried it.

best regards
elmar

[Icecube]

@ elmar: some info about VDI
http://forums.virtualbox.org/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=16217
http://forums.virtualbox.org/viewtopic.php?t=8046

[Elmar]

@ elmar: some info about VDI
http://forums.virtualbox.org/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=16217
http://forums.virtualbox.org/viewtopic.php?t=8046

thanks

[Z_God]

I just came across this tool! I think it would be perfect if one feature could be added:
- support for ext2/3/4 filesystems

This would mean it would be possible to have for example a DEB or RPM file containing a full OS for systems running any GNU/Linux distro. Installing such a package would just add the appropriate entry to the GRUB menu to let it boot another OS straight from an image on your Linux partition.

I can imagine many uses for this:
- easily installable FreeDOS environment for flashing
- testing different distros without repartitioning
- installing an OS like ReactOS for testing by just installing a DEB or RPM package

I'll be looking forward to see continued development of this tool!

[yaab.amir]

[Posting here as VHD Loader page points to this thread]

I see great future for tools like VHD Loader. I would very like to see it evolve.

Virtualization it at its peak these days with increasing rate of Linux distros and debate (even for home users like me) between MS and Linux.

I found VHD Loader since I make an attempt to switch my PCs from MS to Linux. I use virtualization (VirtualBox in my case) to test-bed Linux and made all the adjustments (that for a MS user aren't always straight-forward) but now I want the entire family to switch to the same "image".

There are other solutions such as HDD backup (within VM) and restore (to a physical HDD) but frankly, I would be simply terrific if I could simply keep the MS HDD as it is (until I gain confidence) and work on the VHD directly (full read-write).

I can think of other scenarios where such VHDs become a simple PC deployment tools with VHD Loader.

Yes - I will appreciate boot menu (but you're right - for testing manual selection is OK), VHD read-write from any common file-system, internal and detachable devices.

At any rate - good work and thanks for your efforts.

[zapp]

does people really want to boot without virtual machine from such images?

Yes!

yaab.amir has summed it up nicely here.

and if  NTFS can be used with your loader I think it will be much more popular.

I am booting XP .vhd that has been prepared in VirtualBox using USBoot also so that I can boot through Grub4Dos.

booting .vhd is also the only way I know how to boot more than three versions of windows from the same HDD. (I think Plop might do this but I have not investigated more as I do it this way or ram loaded raw images)

I think what the OP mentioned is the next step, booting an encrypted .vhd, but the bootloaders that the open source encryption tools offer does not support this. (yet?)

I think if anyone can make it happen it is Elmar, Grub4Dos guys, or DiskCryptors author.

[smokingenius]

Elmar,

Thank you so much for this tool. I have been struggling for weeks to find a way to boot something from a .vhd other than windows. I am so glad to have found this tool.

I am unfortunately unable to get it to find either of my FAT32 partitions on my system and therefore can't boot the .vhd drives I have on them. Currently I have a small instance of DSL (Damn Small Linux) on the drive since a larger install of Linux would not be supported by FAT32's 4GB limit. Anyways, I am booting of a cd/dvd and for some reason once the loader kicks off is replies with some dots, ...., then some random letters every time, and then it tells me it is unable to find any FAT32 partitions. I have two externals that the bios can see prior to boot that are both FAT32, one is 1 TB and the other is 80 GB. The 80 GB has the DSL install in a .vhd container on it. Could you please help.

I also would very very very much love to see support added for finding and executing .vhd files off, and now with Windows 8 .vhdx files, from ntfs and ext* file systems.

Also, just for kicks I used EasyBCD to try and boot the ISO through the Windows boot loader menu. It started when I selected it. Problem came in that it once again found no FAT32 partitions.

Please assist and thanks again for a wonderful program.

[Forrestluna]

Similar problem to me, thx for the answers

[smokingenius]

Elmar,

So I have done some further work in attempting to get PLoP VHD loader to work on my machine. I made a partition on my primary boot HDD that was FAT32 and moved my DSL VHD to that partition, and I get the same error. Frustrating, but I am sure it is something I have overlooked.

I look forward to hearing from you soon.

Regards.

[UnChanger]

So I have done some further work in attempting to get PLoP VHD loader to work on my machine. I made a partition on my primary boot HDD that was FAT32 and moved my DSL VHD to that partition, and I get the same error. Frustrating, but I am sure it is something I have overlooked.

Maybe the VHD file itself is not defragmented? (Note: I'm about the VHD file, and not the drive inside it)
I've seen such issue in Grub4Dos when VHD file was fragmented on the physical drive, and in Grub4DOS you need to defrag the VHD file for mapping as hard disk. (Here's the note from Grub4dos guide: http://diddy.boot-land.net/grub4dos/files/map.htm).

So, defrag the VHD file using tools like Contig or WinContig and try again. Waiting for your feedback

[UnChanger]

Nice to see this nice VHD-boot software.
Tried it, and it worked fine on first run!

Plop boot manager has its own place near the Grub and Grub4Dos because of it's portability and nice-and-simple interface.
Though Windows added native VHD support and Grub4DOS also works with VHDs,  I (like many others) would like to see VHD loader going up like Plop Boot (and maybe merge with it)

Here are some good points:
Could you, please, add NTFS support? As other users noted, it will make the program more popular and more useful
I think Grub4DOS sources can help you to achieve them easier way: https://sourceforge.net/projects/grub4dos)
Also adding support of Differencing VHDs would be a great step forward (p.s. Grub and Grub4Dos don't support it).
It can add lots of good possibilities like "fast recovery" of system (which was booted from VHD) to previous state (simply by deleting the differencing image) and so on (IMO it could be useful in lots of real-life situations, started from internet-clubs to real servers). I can give you more info on this point.

Thanks a lot for the tool, waiting for the next test-version with a great pleasure

Best Regards, UnChanger

[Elmar]

Its planned that VHD support will be part of the new boot manager, but at the moment, VHD has only low priority.

Best regards
Elmar

[IBIT.ZEE]

Yeah... NTFS support would be Nice in VHDLoader...

Please give it a try...